Soil Science Society of America

Direct steam distillation as an alternative to the illinois soil nitrogen test

Development of the Illinois Soil N Test (ISNT) has rejuvenated the search for a soil-based N test to measure potentially mineralizable soil N. Accurate quantification of amino sugar N has been achieved using the ISNT, but issues concerning sample variability and analysis time have led to the discovery of a 10 mol L–1 NaOH direct steam distillation (DSD) procedure. Our primary objective was to determine if DSD could be used as a reliable alternative to the ISNT. Laboratory experiments were conducted to compare the two methods based on recovery of N from pure organic compounds, specificity tests to determine amine group hydrolysis, and recovery of 15N-labeled glucosamine N added to soils. Both methods recovered appreciable amounts of amino sugar N from pure compounds and the ISNT had a higher recovery of N from all amino sugar compounds. Recovery of N from glutamine and asparagine was higher using DSD. Direct 15N techniques for recovery of glucosamine N added to six soils showed no significant difference between the two methods within a soil, but resulted in significant differences among soils. Glucosamine-15N recovery significantly and positively correlated with soil total N. Although the ISNT and DSD measure different amounts of amino sugar N and transition amino acid N, they recover relatively the same amount of hydrolyzable N for a given soil, indicating that differences between the methods may not be that significant as both appear to quantify a pool of potentially mineralizable N. Direct steam distillation appears to be a viable alternative to the ISNT in correlation and calibration of crop response for N-fertilizer recommendations due to the short analysis time per sample (~6 min) and the accurate estimation of potentially mineralizable N.

Customer comments

No comments were found for Direct steam distillation as an alternative to the illinois soil nitrogen test. Be the first to comment!