'The vastness of our oceans may have engendered a sense of complacency about potential impacts from global climate change,' said Dr. Jane Lubchenco, a marine biologist at Oregon State University, who moderated the panel. 'The world's oceans are undergoing profound physical, chemical and biological changes whose impacts are just beginning to be felt.'
Panelist Gretchen Hofmann, a molecular physiologist at the University of California-Santa Barbara, describes the situation as 'multiple jeopardy.'
'Ocean ecosystems are facing new stresses and new combinations of stress,' Hofmann said. 'The water is warmer, circulation patterns are changing in unpredictable ways, and oceans are becoming acidic.'
Michael Behrenfeld, an oceanographer from Oregon State University, is studying relationships between climate and the global activity of ocean plants called phytoplankton.
'Phytoplankton are of tremendous human importance because their photosynthesis yields oxygen for us to breathe and they are the base of the ocean food webs that support our global fisheries,' Behrenfeld explained.
Despite their microscopic size, ocean phytoplankton are responsible for about half of the photosynthesis on Earth, a process that removes carbon dioxide from the atmosphere and converts it into organic carbon to fuel nearly every ocean ecosystem.
Using NASA satellites, Behrenfeld and other scientists are tracking changes in phytoplankton on a global basis and finding that warming ocean temperatures are linked to decreasing photosynthesis.
Satellites aid understanding of the link between climate and ocean biology because they provide measurements of the whole planet on a daily basis, yet now the Behrenfeld worries that 'we are facing the end of NASA ocean biology satellites because of budget cutbacks or new priorities.'
'Instead of facing the end of these critical missions and becoming blind to the changes occurring in our oceans,' Behrenfeld said, 'we should be building even better ones to see more clearly than we have in the past, and to gauge the potential consequences of climate change on ocean productivity.'
The panelists also called for greater investment in ocean observing systems that would allow scientists to better measure changing in the ocean ecosystem, including large-scale circulation and coastal upwelling systems around the world.
Rising greenhouse gas emissions are warming the world's oceans and providing a new threat to coral reefs, which already are among the most threatened of all marine ecosystems, the panelists say.
Even modest warming of a degree or two above normal maximum temperatures can cause a breakdown in the relationship between corals and their symbiotic algae, zooxanthellae, said Nancy Knowlton, a marine biologist with the Smithsonian Institution.
Without zooxanthellae, corals appear white, or 'bleached,' and grow more slowly. They also are more susceptible to disease and may not reproduce.
In 1998 there were worldwide mass bleaching events, Knowlton pointed out, affecting 80 percent of the corals in the Indian Ocean, 20 percent of which died.
In 2005, severe bleaching occurred over much of the Caribbean as a result of overly warm water temperatures.
'We have already lost some 80 percent of the reef corals in the Caribbean over the last three decades, and losses in the Pacific Ocean also are widespread and severe,' Knowlton said.
'Reefs are like cities, with some parts growing and some parts being destroyed, and only when net growth is positive can reefs persist. These reefs already are under threat to overfishing and local pollution and unless drastic action to reduce greenhouse gas emissions is taken soon,' she said, 'these reefs will cease to exist as we know them.'
These same greenhouse gas emissions also are creating dramatic buildup of atmospheric carbon dioxide, CO2, which is making the world's oceans more acidic, said panelist Scott Doney of the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution.
Current CO2 levels of 380 parts per million already are 30 percent higher than pre-industrial values and many scientific models predict that those rates will triple by the end of the century under 'business as usual' scenarios.
While much of the scientific attention on ocean acidification has looked at the impact of coral reefs, the potential danger to other marine ecosystems is equally severe, Doney said.
'Ocean acidification harms plants and animals that form shells from calcium carbonate,' he said. 'Calcifying organisms include not just corals, but many plankton, pteropods [marine snails], clams and oysters, and lobsters. Many of these organisms provide critical food sources or habitats for other organisms and the impact of acidification on food webs and higher trophic levels is not well understood.'
'Newly emerging evidence suggests that larval and juvenile fish may also be susceptible to changes in ocean pH levels,' Doney added. 'Ocean acidification is rapidly becoming a real problem.'
Klaus Keller of Penn State University reported on the economic costs and benefits of effective ocean observing systems to detect changes in the North Atlantic.
Jack Barth, an oceanographer at Oregon State University, said low oxygen dead zones that have appeared on the Pacific Northwest coast since 2000 are unprecedented over the last five decades of scientific observation and likely linked to stronger, more persistent winds that are expected to occur with global warming, he said.
The California Current System provides a case study for similar changes in coastal upwelling zones off South America, southern Africa and northern Africa, Barth said.
'One of the things we've observed is how wind patterns have changed and greatly affected upwelling,' Barth said. 'Two decades ago, the winds would last for three or four days, and then subside. Now they persist for 20 to 40 days before settling down. This creates significant impacts on upwelling and biological productivity, but these impacts can swing wildly from one extreme to another and have been difficult to predict.'
The AAAS symposium was organized by the Partnership for Interdisciplinary Studies of Coastal Oceans, a multi-university research effort headquartered at Oregon State University.